Stepping-up Now: Researching Social Media

In an era when undergraduate students emerge digitally engaged, the progressive graduate educator is one who is open to adapt and adjust the delivery of their teaching, assignments, and interactions to incorporate innovative technology. Faculty face both implicit and explicit expectations in order to engage and enhance the learning process for today’s student. Embracing this posture and pursuit needs to be approached collectively rather than by individual faculty alone.

Graphic reading "Social Media in Education" written over the icons for several social media apps.

Current Challenges
With over 100 social media tools now available it can seem overwhelming to know where to start with determining what to choose, why, and how to use it well. Some faculty have already begun to use social media tools in their classes on campus and in online, blended, or flipped classes. However, significant challenges remain. Beyond technical issues and inadequate support to resolve them, institutional policies and guidelines are either unclear or non-existent, as is training in etiquette when using of social media in an educational context.

While some faculty may wish to explore educational benefits in using social media in their class, others don’t consider themselves “tech savvy” and feel they have inadequate training about how to integrate social media into their courses, and some remain unconvinced that this is a worthwhile educational endeavor. Valid questions arise!

  • Will using social media create unnecessary “busyness” and be an additional distraction?
  • How can we use these tools without violating privacy and FERPA regulations?
  • What empirical evidence do we have to indicate social media may be an asset to educators and student learning processes?

Various Affordances of Social Media
There is a diversity of digital resources and rich multi-media components that can indeed be incorporated into student learning tasks to produce creative, alternative formats and accelerated learning modalities. Social media tools provide stimulating opportunity for students to access diverse views and perspectives from a broad audience, including subject-area specialists (collective intelligence).

They facilitate processing of ideas and concepts through collaborative analyzing, ranking, rating, discussing, and annotating resources. Together students can evaluate and critique materials and concepts to produce metacognition.[1] This process is definitely a desirable educational outcome.

Additionally, student self-directed study and higher-order knowledge retention can be fostered and developed through the utilization of active learning principles with social media tools. A well-designed and facilitated learning community can assist students to learn through negotiated meaning as they study and process together.

Research Conducted Thus Far
Qualitative research has been undertaken assessing student engagement as a result of using social media. Findings suggest there is positive engagement resulting in “presence, social presence, social interaction, and sense of community” (Walker, 2007, Preamble).

However, a study of 29 of the most recent dissertations on the use of social media in education reveals a scarcity of empirical research of the assessment of educational outcomes for student learning, knowledge retention, and skills development (Piotrowski, 2015). Most papers seem to conclude that using social media increased student engagement, and therefore, outcomes were achieved in regard to student interaction. These findings provide a good platform from which to move forward.

The Need for Empirical Research
Further research on the educational effectiveness of social media tools is required to fully evaluate what, if any, specific student learning outcomes are achieved when using the various tools. Ideally this research will assess specific social media tools that provide differing educational affordances such as:

  • Content curation and aggregation using tools such as Learninst and Storify, and bookmarking tools like Diigo.
  • Collaboration tools such as Trello and Padlet.
  • Creation and remix using tools, using tools like Smore, Thinglink, and Animoto.
  • Social networking using tools such as Instagram, LinkedIn, and Google+.

From the categories mentioned above, I would propose data be collected from two sample group populations, one group using social media tools and the other not using them. An evaluation instrument for learning outcome assessment of students’ knowledge retention, skills, and content mastery would be administered to both sample groups. This research, conducted across each educational affordance area, would begin to provide a solid basis for moving forward with the integration and appropriate use of various social media tools within classes. We would have the answers to the questions regarding what to use, and why. Then we can more effectively address the “how”!

Now is the Time
Our experience of the somewhat “haphazard” evolution of online education begs that we approach the integration of social media with collective wisdom, foresight, and planning. If we find that research provides data that empirically validates the educational benefits of various social media tools, then institutions, educators, and administrators will need to collaborate and strategize to produce appropriate guidelines and policies to implement their use. Technological advances and student digital engagement now require us to step-up to the plate collectively in order to move forward in a manner that enhances the learning process for our students.Ron Hannaford

Ronald G. Hannaford

Director of Digital Learning and Program Development
Biola University
ron.hannaford@biola.edu

 

References

  • Bransford, John D., Brown Ann L., and Cocking Rodney R. (2000). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.
  • Chick, Nancy. “Metacognition”, Center for Teaching, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN. https://cft.vanderbilt.edu/guides-sub-pages/metacognition/ accessed March 10, 2016
  • Piotrowski, C. 2015. “Emerging Research on Social Media Use in Education: A Study of Dissertations.” Research in Higher Education Journal, 27
  • Walker, Brian K. 2007. “Bridging the Distance: How Social Interaction, Presence, Social Presence, and Sense of Community Influence Student Learning Experiences in an Online Virtual Environment.” Dissertation, Greensboro, NC: University of North Carolina.

[1] “Metacognition is, put simply, thinking about one’s thinking” (Chick).  Metacognitive practices help students become aware of their strengths and weaknesses as learners, writers, readers, test-takers, group members, etc.  A key element is recognizing the limit of one’s knowledge or ability and then figuring out how to expand that knowledge or extend the ability (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, p. 67).

4 Comments

  1. Posted May 3, 2016 at 12:17 pm | Permalink | Reply

    I co-authored a paper on this subject, published Jan 2016: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26001748. Students used LinkedIn, Google+, and Pinterest. The platform selection was their choice.

    Abstract: This case study shows how students used online social media to disseminate curated knowledge to the public. This is a “redefined” way of having the students show that they have analyzed the existing knowledge on a topic, synthesized/reorganized it in a meaningful way, and created a new presentation of that knowledge in various ways. This case study demonstrates an effective teaching approach to ensure that students develop competencies in teamwork, collaboration, and informatics.

    • Ron Hannaford
      Posted May 9, 2016 at 12:45 pm | Permalink | Reply

      Hi Marc,

      Thank you for providing the link to your team’s valuable research. It is a fascinating report, and revealed many of the benefits of incorporating SM into class assignments – particularly curation tools. I would also encourage exploring the options of using the Learnist curation tool for future projects, in light of some of the difficulties that emerged in your trial.

      The report raised several very pertinent issues that both students and faculty face when using SM, and it supports the need for intentional institutional support of such educational endeavors. I presented a paper on such issues at the DT&L Conference in Madison, WI, in August 2015. If you would like to review that paper, let me know.

      I wish you well with your future SM research efforts.

      Ron

  2. Lauren
    Posted April 6, 2016 at 11:34 am | Permalink | Reply

    Hi — this is very interesting research and information. I understand the focus of this post is the use of social media in student learning. Is there any information available re: social media and alumni engagement?

    • Posted April 6, 2016 at 4:49 pm | Permalink | Reply

      Hi Lauren,

      You are correct that the focus of this post questions whether student learning is accomplished when incorporating social media in class design, and the need for research to discover what the learning outcomes really are.

      However, I have not been involved with university communication and marketing nor the alumni office in their use of social media. However, I think there may have been research undertaken in these realms that assesses social media, and informs departments in their use of social media to promote universities and their services and foster alumni interaction. Undertaking a dissertation search in one of the library data search engines, or alternatively searching Google academic, may reveal some of these studies.

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*
*

%d bloggers like this: